Nancy Guthrie’s Disappearance Triggered A Series Of Ransom Notes — But The One Message Investigators Say Stands Apart From All The Others Is What People Can’t Stop Talking About

One of the chilling ransom notes sent to Nancy Guthrie’s heartbroken family included a disturbing apology for accidentally killing her, according to a dramatic new report.

The disturbing Feb. 6 email was sent to TMZ from the same IP address as earlier blackmail letters that were packed with eerie details about the night Guthrie — mother of “Today” host Savannah Guthrie — was snatched from her Arizona home, including what she was wearing, sources close to the case told Air Mail.

The purported abductor had initially demanded $4 million in bitcoin in a Feb. 2 note, described Guthrie as “safe but scared,” and spelled out terms for an exchange — convincing investigators they were dealing with the real kidnappers rather than sick internet pranksters.

Nancy Guthrie, mother of "Today" show anchor Savannah Guthrie, smiling while playing Mahjong.
One of the chilling ransom notes sent to Nancy Guthrie’s heartbroken family included a disturbing apology for accidentally killing her.Courtesy NBC Universal

However, a follow-up note on Feb. 6 opened with a bizarre, rambling “apology” for her accidental death, the outlet claimed.

It then suggested the 84-year-old kidnap victim’s body could be returned for a price, though no specific amount was given, the outlet’s sources said.

The ransom note was credited with shifting the investigation from a kidnapping case to one of potential homicide.

Savannah and Nancy Guthrie dining together.
The sinister email had originated from the same IP address as earlier blackmail letters that were packed with eerie details about the night Guthrie, mother of “Today” host Savannah Guthrie, was abducted.Facebook/Savanah Guthrie

It also sparked the emotional response from Savannah and her siblings, who took to Instagram the next day in a 20-second video saying they had “received your message and we understand.”

She later begged the abductor to “return our mother to us,” adding that her return is “very valuable to us” and that “we will pay.”

After the Air Mail story was published, TMZ reported that the ransom note it received did not say that Guthrie was dead or contain an apology.

TMZ described the the notes it was sent as being from someone who claimed to know who kidnapped Nancy and where she was — but the author denied being the abductor himself.

Guthrie has been missing since Feb. 1 after authorities believed she was kidnapped from her Tucson home.

Investigators around the residence of Nancy Guthrie in Tucson, Arizona.
Guthrie has been missing since Feb. 1 after authorities believed she was kidnapped from her Tucson home. James Keivom for NY Post
Surveillance image of a suspect wearing a balaclava and gloves.
No arrests have been made and no new leads have manifested as the investigation into the mysterious disappearance continues.FBI

A barrage of ransom notes flooded her family and media outlets, including several sent to TMZ, after her disappearance, with investigators sorting the messages into three categories — “the good, the bad, and the ugly” — as they combed through every line and chilling demand, sources told the outlet.

Notes with specific information about Guthrie were deemed “good,” while the one referencing her accidental death was labeled “bad,” the insiders said.

Savannah admitted in a “Today” interview earlier this year that most of the ransom notes sent to her family were fakes — but she added, “I believe the two notes that we received that we responded to, I tend to believe those are real.”

No arrests have been made and no new leads have manifested as the investigation into the mysterious disappearance continues.

Related Posts

Critics were already asking questions after Portugal’s shock World Cup stumble. At 41, many wondered whether the football icon had finally reached the end of the road. But just minutes into his next match, Cristiano Ronaldo did something no player in the history of the tournament had ever done before

Congratulations! You’ve earned 1 point OK Cristiano Ronaldo silences critics just SIX minutes into World Cup clash as he breaks never-before-seen record CRISTIANO RONALDO added another record…

When 14-year-old Lilly Jones vanished with her phone switched off, an entire community came together hoping to bring her home safely. Volunteers searched through the night, helicopters circled overhead, and locals combed areas they believed had already been checked.

Congratulations! You’ve earned 1 point OK Body of ‘murdered’ schoolgirl, 14, found ‘hidden in dense undergrowth’ as locals say they missed her during search Boy, 14, arrested…

At only 24, Denisa Baránková had already done what few athletes ever accomplish: two Olympic appearances, historic milestones for her country, and a gold medal that seemed to signal the beginning of an even brighter chapter. Those closest to her believed the best was still ahead. The next goals, the next competitions, the next dreams were already taking shape.

Congratulations! You’ve earned 1 point OK Two-time Slovakia Olympian dead at 24 after being hit by car Two-time Olympian archer Denisa Baránková died after being struck by…

Country music fans have followed Rory Feek and his daughter Indiana through some of life’s most emotional chapters over the years. Now, the family is facing another difficult moment as Indiana undergoes major heart surgery, prompting Rory to share a deeply personal update about the journey ahead.

Congratulations! You’ve earned 1 point OK Indiana Feek, the only child of the late Joey Feek and her husband Rory Feek, will be undergoing open heart surgery. Indiana Feek…

The Woman Accused Of Dumping A Knicks Trash Can Into A Manhattan Street Became The Subject Of A Viral Video — But The Professional Background That Surfaced After People Identified Her Is What Everyone Is Talking About

Congratulations! You’ve earned 1 point OK A woman caught on video emptying a public trash can on the street then stealing it during New York City’s Knicks championship parade…

World Cup Pundit Faces Explosive Backlash After Controversial Remarks About ‘Black Players’ Spark Racism Row Following Belgian Star’s Red Card ⚽

Congratulations! You’ve earned 1 point OK A World Cup television pundit is facing backlash for racist comments after Nathan Ngoy was sent off for Belgium. Former Atletico Madrid forward…